Suffolk County, NY  ·  Licensed Real Estate Broker  ·  NYS Lic. #10491211411

Buying or Selling a Home
in Shelter Island, NY?

DME REAL ESTATE SERVICES LLC delivers personal, one-on-one real estate service in Shelter Island and across Suffolk County. No assistants. No runaround. Just your broker — directly.

📞 Call (516) 578-7471 💬 Text for Free Valuation
Licensed NYS Broker · #10491211411
Principal Broker: Douglas M. Eberling
Highway Access
Equal Housing Opportunity

Suffolk County · Residential Real Estate

Your Shelter Island, NY
Real Estate Broker

Affluent summer community, year-round island residents, nature lovers, Hamptons adjacent
Shelter Island is Long Island's most serene — ferry-only access, Mashomack Preserve, and Peconic Bay.

Shelter Island is one of Suffolk County's most sought-after communities, attracting buyers who value affluent summer community, year-round island residents, nature lovers, hamptons adjacent. The local residential market features a median sale price of approximately $1,200,000, with demand driven by strong community character and Long Island's enduring appeal.

At DME REAL ESTATE SERVICES LLC, every client works directly with Principal Broker Douglas M. Eberling — a licensed NYS real estate broker (Lic. #10491211411) with hands-on experience across Long Island and Queens. We provide free home valuations, strategic pricing, and aggressive marketing to get your Shelter Island property sold at maximum value.

$1,200,000Median Sale Price
SuffolkCounty
Highway AccessTransit Access

What We Do

How We Help
Shelter Island Buyers & Sellers

Whether you are buying your first home, upgrading to more space, downsizing, or relocating from Queens or Brooklyn to Long Island, DME REAL ESTATE SERVICES LLC provides the personal guidance you need to make a confident decision in Shelter Island's competitive market.

For Sellers: Free CMA, professional listing strategy, MLS exposure, and direct broker negotiation. We price your Shelter Island home accurately and market it aggressively.

For Buyers: Access to all MLS listings, off-market opportunities, and a broker who fights for your best interests from first showing to closing day.

Ready to buy or sell in Shelter Island? Call or text Principal Broker Douglas M. Eberling directly. No assistant, no callback queue — just direct, personal service from a licensed NYS broker.

Frequently Asked Questions

Shelter Island Real Estate
Questions Answered

Who is the best real estate broker in Shelter Island, NY?

DME REAL ESTATE SERVICES LLC, led by Principal Broker Douglas M. Eberling (NYS Lic. #10491211411), provides personal residential real estate services in Shelter Island and Suffolk County, NY. Call (516) 578-7471 for a free consultation.

How much is my house worth in Shelter Island?

The median sale price in Shelter Island is approximately $1,200,000. Your specific value depends on size, condition, location, and recent comparable sales. Contact DME REAL ESTATE SERVICES LLC at (516) 578-7471 for a free, no-obligation Comparative Market Analysis.

How do I sell my house fast in Shelter Island, NY?

Accurate pricing, professional presentation, and strong marketing exposure are the keys to a fast sale in Shelter Island. DME REAL ESTATE SERVICES LLC provides all three. Call (516) 578-7471 for a free seller strategy session.

Is Shelter Island a good place to buy a home in Suffolk County?

Shelter Island is a desirable Suffolk County community known for affluent summer community, year-round island residents, nature lovers, hamptons adjacent. Home values have shown consistent long-term appreciation. Call (516) 578-7471 to discuss what's currently available.

What are closing costs when buying a home in Shelter Island, NY?

New York closing costs typically range from 2%–5% of the purchase price and include title insurance, attorney fees, mortgage tax, and transfer tax. DME REAL ESTATE SERVICES LLC can provide detailed estimates for your specific Shelter Island transaction. Call (516) 578-7471.

Does DME REAL ESTATE SERVICES LLC serve Shelter Island, Suffolk County?

Yes. DME REAL ESTATE SERVICES LLC, NYS Lic. #10491211411, serves residential buyers and sellers throughout Shelter Island, Suffolk County, and all of Long Island and Queens. Principal Broker: Douglas M. Eberling. Call or text (516) 578-7471 anytime.

Equal Housing Opportunity. DME REAL ESTATE SERVICES LLC is a licensed real estate brokerage in the State of New York, licensed by the New York State Department of State, Division of Licensing Services. NYS License #10491211411. Principal Broker: Douglas M. Eberling. We are pledged to the letter and spirit of U.S. policy for equal housing opportunity. We do not discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status, national origin, sexual orientation, gender identity, or any other protected class. Market data is approximate and subject to change. Not legal or financial advice. NYS RPL §442-H Standard Operating Procedures available upon request. Agency Disclosure available prior to any substantive meeting per NYS RPL §443. © 2026 DME REAL ESTATE SERVICES LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Get In Touch

Ready to Buy or Sell
in Shelter Island?

Reach out directly — no forms, no waiting rooms, no assistants. Principal Broker Douglas M. Eberling responds personally.

📞 Call (516) 578-7471 💬 Text Us Now Email Douglas@dmeres.com

Tapping Call opens your phone dialer  ·  Tapping Text opens your SMS app  ·  Tapping Email opens your mail app — pre-filled and ready to send.

📞 Call Now 💬 Text Us